Volume
3 Number 8 August 2024 E-ISSN: 2963-2900 | P-ISSN: 2964-9048 https://jmi.rivierapublishing.id/index.php/rp
The
Effect of Acupressure on Fasting Blood Glucose Levels in Clients with Type II
Diabetes Mellitus
Galih Mahendra Wekoadi, Arwani, Dwi Ari Murti Widigdo
Postgraduate Applied Master Program, Health Polytechnic of
Semarang, Indonesia
Email: [email protected]
Abstract
Diabetes mellitus is a
disease that has a characteristic signs in the from
of an increase in glucose levels exceeding normal range .
The prevalence of diabetes mellitus �is increasing significantly. Currently,
the management �of diet, exercise and use therapy
pharmacological therapy are option in the management of diabetes mellitus. In
addition to these therapies, there are complementary therapies such as
acupressure. The purpose of this study was to prove the acupressure
intervention in influencing fasting blood glucose levels. This research was a
quasi- experimental study with a nonequivalent control group design with pre �
test post � test. This study had 38 respondents whi
were devided into 2 groups and were taken using a consecutive
sampling techniques. This study was conducted from
April 7th 2021 � May 9th 2021. The pre � test and post
-test difference test used the wilcoxone test. The diferent test between groups used Man � Whitney test and
Independent � t test. Study This showed that there were significant
differences before and after treatment in all groups p = < 0.05. The
results of the post-test differences between groups also showed p = 0.012 which
shows that there are meaningful differences between post-tests in groups
intervention and control groups. Complementary therapy in the form of proven
acupressure can decrease fasting blood glucose in type II diabetes mellitus
patients, and complementary therapy in the form of acupressure can used for decrease
fasting blood glucose levels in type II diabetes mellitus patients.
Keywords :
Diabetes
Mellitus Type II, Acupressure, Fasting Blood Glucose
BACKGROUND
Diabetes mellitus is a diseases that has a characteristic sign in the from of an increase in blood glucose levels exceeding
normal range (Listyarini and Fadilah 2017). The prevalence
of people with diabetes mellitus in the world is increasing significantly. The
latest study shows that the number of sufferers with diabetes mellitus in the
world reaches 425 million people, and is even predicted to continue to increase
to reach 629 million in 2045 (Jumari, Waluyo et al. 2019 )
.
Based on RISKESDAS data in 2018 the prevalence
of people with diabetes mellitus in Indonesia 2018 was 2.0 %. The results shows
that there is an increase in the number of sufferers with diabetes mellitus
from the previous year which only showed 1.5% (Kemenkes
RI 2018). Based on these data, Indonesia is a country with the sixth highest
number of sufferers with diabetes mellitus in the world after China, India,
United States, Brazil and Mexico. Diabetes mellitus in
Indonesia is also referred to as the disease with the 3rd most
killer predicate in Indonesia `s population (Jumari, Waluyo et al. 2019).
Central Java is one of the provinces in Indonesia with the largest population
suffering from diabetes mellitus compares to other provinces in Indonesia.
RISKESDAS data in 2018 showed the prevalence of clients with diabetes mellitus
in Central Java reached 2.1% (Kemenkes RI 2018) . In Temanggung Regency, the
number of sufferers with diabetes mellitus is 6477 clients, with details of 109
clients with type I diabetes mellitus and 6368 clients with type II diabetes
mellitus. Compared to other districts and cities in Central Java, Temanggung Regency is ranked 26th �out of a total of 35 districts and cities in
Central Java (Prabawa et al., 2018).
The presence of high blood glucose levels
can cause many complications including coronary heart disease, retinopathy,
hypertension, nephropathy and gangrene (Baynes, 2015), (Carabott et al., 2021), Kowalk, Welsh et al. 2017). Therefore, it is necessary to
control and treat blood glucose levels as early as possible so that these complications
do not occur in the client considering that diabetes mellitus is a disease
suffered by the client for life.
Currently, the management of diet
food, exercise and use of antidiabetic medicine are options for managing
diabetes mellitus (Jamaluddin and Prasetyo 2019).
According to Listyarini and Fadilah, there are 4
pillars of intervention in dealing with the problem of diabetes mellitus, namely
meal management and planning, physical exercise, administration of hypoglycemic
medicine and health education. The provision of �interventions based on 4 pillars of diabetes
mellitus management has proven to be effective in reducing blood glucose levels
in clients with diabetes mellitus, but in practice, it has not worked
perfectly, this is �supported by the 2018
RISKESDAS data which shows that diabetes mellitus control intervention with
food control only 80.2 %, the exercise intervention shows the proportion of
success is 48.1% and �the diabetes
mellitus intervention with medicine has a success �percentage of 91% ( Kemenkes
RI 2018)
Some of the reasons that cause
client with diabetes mellitus not to take anti-diabetic medicine include : feeling healthy, not regularly going to health
facilities, taking� traditional medicine,
often forgetting, cannot stand the side effects of medicine, cannot afford to
buy medicine regularly and medicine are not available in health facilities (Kemenkes RI 2018). Therefore other
therapies are needed to overcome the problem of diabetes mellitus, especially
high blood glucose levels.
In recent years, complementary
therapies have emerged it can be used to treat high blood glucose levels in
diabetes mellitus, such as reflexology and wet cupping (Zarvasi,
Jaberi et al. 2018, Jumari, Waluyo et al. 2019). Other complementary therapies
that can be applied to improve blood glucose levels in patients with diabetes
mellitus are Chinese complementary therapies such as acupuncture therapy,
acupressure therapy, herbs and qi gong therapy
(Jumari, Waluyo et al. 2019).
In Temanggung
regency, it was found that massage therapy is widely used by the community to
treat various diseases. This phenomenon is supported by the results of
interviews conducted by researchers in a preliminary study on May 1st,
2020, with a patient with diabetes mellitus named Mrs. S (55 years). The result
of the interview found that the client said, �I believe if my blood glucose level
decrease after a massage at a certain point because I have taken measurements
using a glucometer and the blood glucose level dcrease
in the body because it doesn`t feel weak. It`s been proven a lot. Therefore, it
is necessary to look for complementary therapies that have been proven to
reduce blood glucose levels in clients with diabetes mellitus, but conceptually
have similarities with massage therapy. One of the complementary therapies that
have been proven in research in decrease blood glucose levels of clients with
diabetes mellitus and has the same concept as massage therapy is complementary
acupressure therapy.
Complementary medicine from China that
is used in overcoming the problem of blood glucose levels in patients with
diabetes mellitus is to use acupressure therapy. Acupuncture and acupressure
therapy techniques are the same because they use the same meridian points. The
acupressure technique is considered more appropriate to be applied to people
with diabetes mellitus because the acupressure technique used is the fingers so
that it does not cause fear to the client compared to acupuncture which uses a
needle in the form of a needle (Jumari, Waluyo et al. 2019). Complementary
acupressure therapy was also chosen because conceptually, complementary
acupressure therapy is almost the same as massage, but has been modified with
emphasis on only a few acupoints (Jumari, Waluyo et al. 2019, Manek 2019). In
addition, complementary acupressure therapy is also one of the complementary
therapies that have minimal risk in people with diabetes mellitus (Rousdy, 2017).
Several studies have shown that
acupressure therapy is more effective in decrease blood glucose levels,
compared to regular treatment in the form of antidiabetic medicine (Fitrullah and Rousdy 2016, Masithoh, Ropi et al. 2016,
Jamaluddin and Prasetyo 2019, Jumari, Waluyo et al.
2019). Complications due to diabetes mellitus can also be reduced because of
this therapy. One of the studies that showed that the administration of
acupressure was effective in reducing blood glucose levels was a study conducted
by Jamaluddin and Prasetyo on acupressure therapy on
blood glucose balance in Type 2 diabetes mellitus in the work area of the Jumpandang Baru Health Center Makasar.
In this study, it was concluded that giving acupressure affected reducing blood
glucose levels in clients with diabetes mellitus.
Similar research was also conducted
by Jumari et al. The results of the study concluded that acupressure therapy
affected decreaseing blood glucose levels in patients
with diabetes mellitus compared to standard therapy for diabetes mellitus using
anti � diabetic medicine. In this study, the administration of acupressure
therapy was shown to be able to reduce current blood glucose levels in clients
with diabetes mellitus within 3 weeks.
Acupressure therapy has been proven
statistically effective in reducing blood glucose levels, but clinically this
therapy has not been shown to have a significant effect on reducing blood
glucose levels in clients with diabetes mellitus in other words, it has reached
the cut of point of blood glucose levels according to WHO (World Health
Organization). This is evidenced in the study of Jumari et al. which shows that
before acupressure the client`s current blood glucose is 258, 88 mg / dL and
after acupressure, it drops to 229, 69 mg / dL (has not reached the normal
value of current blood glucose according to WHO, which is < 200 mg / dL). In
this study, it can also be seen that the effect size value for acupressure
therapy in this study was 0,4 or it can be concluded that acupressure therapy
has a good effect on reducing blood glucose.
Based
on the evaluation carried out by researchers in previous studies, it can be seen that in previous studies the acupressure
intervention was carried out as a substitution intervention rather than a
complementary intervention. In addition, in previous studies, the management of
diabetes mellitus was not carried out thoroughly by following per under the
four pillars of diabetes mellitus management
�Based on the background above, the researcher
is interested in conducting research entitled �The Effect of Acupressure on
Fasting Blood Glucose Levels in Clients with Type II Diabetes Mellitus�.
Objective
The purpose
of this study was to prove the acupressure intervention in influencing fasting
blood glucose levels in clients with type II diabetes mellitus.
RESEARCH
METHODS
This researchh
is a quasi experiment study a nonequivalent control
group design with pre � test post � test . This study
was conducted from April 7th 2021 � May 9th2021. The
population in this study were clients with type II diabetes mellitus who
experienced hyperglycemia in the work area of the Bulu Health Center, Temanggung Regency and participated in the PROLANIS
program. The sample in this study was taken using a consecutive sampling
technique and obtained a sample of 38 samples for two groups (19 respondents /
group).
In the intervention group
acupressure was given for 5 minutes at points ST � 36 and SP � 6 on the left
and right legs for 6 treatments within 3 weeks (1 week 2 treatments). In the
intervention group, respondents still consume pharmacology therapy prescribed
by a doctor. In the control group was only given standard treatment in the form
of anti- hyperglycemia medicine prescribed by a doctor.
Data processing in this study was
computerized using parametric and non- parametric tests. In conducting this
research, the researcher pays attention to research ethics which include : informed consent, confidentiality, justice,
ethical clearance and beneficence.
RESULTS
AND DISCUSSION
1. Respondents Fasting Blood Glucose Level
Table 1. Blood Glucose Levels Pre and Post
|
Fasting
Blood Glucose Levels |
Intervention
Group n = 19 |
Control
Group n = 19 |
|
Fasting
Blood Glucose Levels Pre - Test (mg/dL) Mean + SD (min � max) |
211.8 �
73.5 (130 �
376) |
273.05 �
102.4 (131 �
477) |
|
Fasting
Blood Glucose Levels Post - Test (mg/dL) mean + SD (min �
max) |
136.05 +
37.2 (73 � 210) |
181.3 +
64.3 (73 � 327) |
2. Hypothesis Testing
Table 2. Different Test of Pre � Test and Post Test Fasting Blood
Glucose
|
Group |
|
Median (Minimum �
Maximum) mg/dL |
p |
|
Intervention |
Pre-Test |
184 (130 �
376) |
0,000 |
|
Post -
Test |
126 (73 � 210) |
||
|
Control |
Pre-Test |
218 (131 �
477) |
0,000 |
|
Post -
Test |
172 (73 � 327) |
Table 3. Different Test of Fasting Blood Glucose Levels in the
Intervention Group and the Control Group
|
|
Group |
Median (Minimum �
Maximum) mg/dL |
p |
|
|
Pre-Test |
Intervention |
184 (130 �
376) |
0.563 |
|
|
Control |
218 (131 �
477) |
|
||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mean
(mg/dL) |
p |
Mean
Difference (95%
Confidence Interval of the Difference) |
|
Post -
Test |
Intervention |
136, 05
(37, 2) |
0.012 |
-45, 31
(-80,1 - -10,7) |
|
Control |
181, 37
(64, 3) |
Discussion
1.
The
Effect of Acupressure Therapy on Fasting Blood Glucose Levels
In intervention groups, the results
of the Wilcoxone test showed that H 0 was
rejected (p < 0.05) so it was said that there was an effect of acupressure
on fasting blood glucose levels of respondents in intervention group after being
given acupressure treatment for 5 minutes at 2 acupoints 2 times in 1 week for
3 weeks. The results of research are by following per under the results of
previous studies. Previous research on acupressure on diabetes mellitus clients
conducted by Jumari, Agung Waluyo, Wati Jumaiyah and Dhea Natashia (2019), showed that acupressure was proven to
reduce blood glucose levels in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus.
Compared with the acupressure treatment
in previous studies, this study was considered to be
better in lowering blood glucose levels. The results of statistical analysis
showed that both studies proved that complementary therapy in the form of
acupressure lower blood glucose levels of client with type II diabetes
mellitus, but both have not been effective in reducing blood glucose levels,
because they have not reached the cut off point value
set by WHO (World Health Organization).
A similar study was conducted by Maryam
Jamaluddin and Wahyuni Maria Prasetyo, who said that
acupressure intervention can reduce blood glucose in patients with type 2
diabetes mellitus. The results of this study are in line with the results of
this study. When compared statistically both are proven to decrease glucose
levels, but are not effective. Besides based on previous research, Nanda`s
nursing diagnosis also recommends this complementary acupressure therapy as one
of the complementary therapies that nurses can do (Khusna,
Sudirman et al. 2019.
Acupressure has an influence on decreasing
fasting blood glucose levels in patient with type II diabetes mellitus because
acupressure can stimulate neurotransmitters whose job is to carry signals to
nerves or through glands so that the hypothalamus will be active (Jumari,
Waluyo et al. 2019). The hypothalamus is defined as the control center of
the body which is connected with a lot of nerves and
the pituitary gland. The presence of stimulation in the hypothalamus will
trigger it to release CRH (Corticotropin Releasing Hormone) which functions as a
stimulus to the anterior pituitary gland (Sulastri and Arofi
2018). Then the pituitary gland will produce the ACTH (
Adrenocorticotropic ) hormone which functions to stimulate the adrenal gland
in the zona fasciculata to produce cortisol whose main task is to control blood
glucose levels through the process of increasing carbohydrates.
Providing bodily Giving the body a stimulus
in the form of emphasis on the SP � 6 and ST � 36 points can produce glucose �
6 � phosphate which is one enzyme used in carbohydrates metabolism and also responds to the hypothalamus � pituitary � adrenal
AXIS and produces the hormone CRF (Corticotropin Releasing Factor) so that
pancreas especially B cells � Langerhan will be stimulated
to secretes insulin (Syafitri, Berawi
et al. 2019). In level At the cellular level, the target cell of this acupressure
therapy is the glucose transporter (GLTU � 4) whose job it is to carry glucose
into cells, so that a decrease in blood glucose levels will occur (Jumari,
Waluyo et al. 2019) . Basically, the
implementation of acupressure on clients who experience hyperglycemia diabetes
mellitus is focused on the flow of energy / qi to the pituitary gland and
hypothalamus.
2.
Influence
Intervention Standard Against Fasting Blood Sugar Levels
In the control group, the wicoxone test showed that there was a significant
difference in the form of a decrease in fasting blood glucose levels of
respondents before and after being given standard treatment in the form of an anti-
hyperglycemic medicine in the form of metformin 500 mg. Metformin works by
lowering blood glucose levels through insulin target cells in the liver,
muscle, and fat by increasing the sensitivity of these cells to insulin. The
anti- hyperglycemia medicine metformin also works by decreasing gluconeogenesis
in the liver, thereby decreasing fasting blood glucose levels (Diani and Pulungan 2010, Katzung, Masters et al. 2012)
3.
Comparison
Between Group
The pre-test of blood
glucose levels t-test between the two groups using the Man
Whitney test showed that p = 0,563 (p
< 0,05) which means that there was no
significant difference in the base line data between the two groups before
being given treatment, both standard treatment and treatment in the form of
complementary acupressure therapy performed twice a week for 3 weeks of
treatment. In the post-test data, the statistical test results
with the independent t-test p = 0,012 which
showed that there was a significant difference in the post-test
data between the intervention and control groups.
In this analysis, it can be seen that the use
of intervention in the form of complementary acupressure therapy has a better
reduction in blood glucose levels compared to those who are only given standard
therapy by using anti-hyperglycemia
medicine in the form of metformin. This is shown by the average value of
post-test data between the two groups. In the intervention group with the
provision of treatment in the form of complementary acupressure therapy, the
average post-test value of fasting blood glucose levels was
136,05 mg / dL and it was only
181,3 mg / dL in the
control group.
In the
intervention group, the post-test showed that blood glucose
levels were better than in the control group because in the
intervention group, acupressure had an influence on reducing fasting blood glucose
levels in type 2 diabetes mellitus patients because it
can stimulate neurotransmitters which carry
signals between nerves or through glands so that the
hypothalamus will be active (Jumari, Waluyo et al. 2019). The stimulation of
the hypothalamus will trigger it to release CRH (Corticotropin Releasing Hormone)
which functions as a stimulus to the anterior pituitary gland (Sulastri and Arofi 2018). The anterior pituitary gland will produce ACTH
(Adrenocorticotropic) which functions to stimulate the adrenal glands of the
fasciculate zone to produce cortisol controlling blood glucose
levels through the process of carbohydrate binding.
Providing stimulus
at acupoint points SP � 6 and ST � 36 can
produce glucose � 6 phospate which is
one of the enzymes used in carbohydrate metabolism and also
responds to hypothalamus � pituitary � adrenal AXIS
and produces CRF (Corticotropin Releasing Factor) so that the pancreas,
especially B cell � Langerhan, will
be stimulated to excrete insulin (Syafitri, Berawi et al. 2019). In this intervention group, patients were also required to
continue taking anti-hyperglycemia medicine in the form of metformin. Metformin
is a medicine that works by lowering blood glucose levels through insulin
target cells in the liver, muscle and fat by
increasing insulin sensitivity. It also works
by reducing gluconeogenesis in the liver so that blood glucose levels will decrease.
In the
intervention group, it can be concluded that the treatments
in reducing fasting blood glucose levels can carried
out in two ways, namely by using complementary acupressure therapy and
pharmacological therapy in the form of anti-hyperglycemia medicine, so that the
results obtained can be maximized.
4.
Limitations
Study
a.
There was no randomization in sampling
because there might be treatment bias due to respondents who meet one another in the community.
b.
In this study, researchers did not control
confounding variables.
CONCLUSION
The conclusion that can be drawn from this study is
that the provision of complementary therapy in the form of acupressure is
proven to have an effect in reducing the fasting blood glucose levels of
patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Baynes, H. W. (2015). Classification, pathophysiology, diagnosis and
management of diabetes mellitus. J Diabetes Metab, 6(5), 1�9.
Carabott, M., Formosa, C., Mizzi, A., Papanas, N., & Gatt, A. (2021).
Thermographic Characteristics of the Diabetic Foot with Peripheral Arterial
Disease Using the Angiosome Concept. Experimental and Clinical Endocrinology
and Diabetes, 129(2), 93�98. https://doi.org/10.1055/a-0838-5209
Prabawa, P. A., Claramita, M., & Pramantara, I. D. P. (2018).
Patients� and families� experiences in Lung Tuberculosis treatment in Kebumen
District, Central Java Province: A phenomenology study of �Drop Out�and
�Uninterrupted�groups. Review of Primary Care Practice and Education (Kajian
Praktik Dan Pendidikan Layanan Primer), 1(3), 105�115.
Rousdy, A. (2017). Effectiveness of acupressure at the Zusanli (ST-36)
acupoint as a comfortable treatment for diabetes mellitus: a pilot study in
Indonesia. Journal of Acupuncture and Meridian Studies, 10(2), 96�103.
Diani, A. and AB Pulungan (2010). "Metformin Management of Type 2
Diabetes Mellitus in Children Compared with Other Oral Anti-Diabetes
Drugs." Pediatrics 11 (6): 395
- 400.
Jamaluddin, M. and WM Prasetyo (2019). "Acupressure Therapy on Blood Glucose
Balance in Type 2 DM Patients in the Jumpandang Baru
Health Center Working Area, Makassar. Makassar Health Polytechnic Health
Media." Makassar Health Polytechnic Health Media 14 (2): 181 - 185.
Jumari, J., et al. (2019). "The Effect of Acupressure
on Blood Glucose Levels of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus Patients at Persadia Islamic Hospital Jakarta Cempaka Putih."
Journal of Telenursing (JOTING) 1 (1):
38 - 50.
Katzung, B.G., et al. (2012). Basic & Clinical Pharmacology. Jakarta, EGC
Medical Book Publisher.
Indonesian Ministry of Health (2018). Main results of riskesdas 2018. Jakarta, Indonesian Ministry of Health.
Khusna, LU, et al. (2019). "Implementation of electrical
acupressure toward fasting blood sugar levels in type II diabetes mellitus
patients in the working area of Jepon Community
Health Center Blora District." International
Journal of Allied Medical Sciences and Clinical Research 7 (3).
Kowalk, J.P., et al. (2017). Jakarta Pathophysiology
Textbook, EGC Medical Book Publishers.
Listyarini, AD and A. Fadilah (2017). "Brisk Walking can reduce
blood glucose levels in diabetes mellitus sufferers in Klumpit
Village, Gebog District, Kudus Regency." Primary
Scholars Journal of Nursing and Public Health 6 (2).
Manek, B.D. (2019). The Effect of Giving SP - 3 Acupressure
with Cardamom Aromatherapy on the Emetogenic Status and Emesis Gravidarum of
Pregnant Women in the First Trimester. Master of Applied Midwifery. Semarang,
Semarang Ministry of Health Polytechnic.
Masithoh, RF, et al. (2016). "The Effect of Acupressure Therapy
on Blood Sugar Levels in Type II Diabetes Mellitus Patients at the Internal
Medicine Polyclinic at Tk II Dr. Soedjono Magelang Hospital." Journal of Holistic Nursing
Science 3 (2): 26 - 37.
Sulastri, S. and TM Arofi (2018). "Controlling Blood Glucose Levels in
Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus Patients Using Lafidzi 21
Healthy Exercises." National Health Research Journal 2 (1): 1 - 8.
Syafitri, D., et al. (2019). "Regular Physical Activity As a Modulator of Insulin Sensitivity in Obesity." Jumantik Journal 5 (1):
9 - 22.
Terry, C. L. and A. Weaver (2013).
Critical Nursing DeMYSTiFieD. Yogyakarta, Rapha
Publishing.
Zarvasi, A., et al. (2018). "Effect of self - acupressure on
fasting blood sugar (FBS) and insulin levels in type 2 diabetes patients : a randomized clinical trial." Electronic
Physician 10 (8).
�����������